Seeking Cover Input

In lieu of actually editing my manuscript, I chose to play around with cover ideas. Because what's the point of doing something productive, when goofing off is more entertaining? 

Originally, I'd found a royalty-free image on Pixabay that I loved, but unfortunately when I slapped the resulting cover onto an epub and pulled it up on my Kindle Reader app, I discovered that it looked ghastly. I mean, really, really bad---amateurish. The photo claimed all the cover space because its size couldn't be reduced (believe me, I tried). But enough about bad choices.

So, back I went to Pixabay. I tend to be too stubborn to easily discard an idea, even when it clearly won't work out, but I finally surrendered and plugged in a few different search terms, such as "broken", "shattered", "cracked". At the heart of the novel is a story about a dysfunctional family, so that's the theme I want to convey with my cover. (The ornate picture frame, sans family photo, instead revealing the cracked wall behind it would have been perfect. Alas, it just didn't work.)

Thus, here are a few possibles:

 

 

If I choose to go with any of them, they'll need some revisions as far as title placement (plus, the author name will need to be enlarged a bit). 

 

So, what do you think? How eye-catching would any of them be? Do they convey the theme? Appropriate colors? There's one design I'm not thrilled with, but I won't try to sway the vote. Nothing is set in stone, and who knows? I may end up going back to the drawing board. But this is what I've got for now.

 

Thanks for your opinion!