Maybe I'm Too Overwrought About AI
A songwriter friend of ours has fallen for AI (Suno, to be exact). In the last couple of days he's sent us three of his songs that AI "improved". I haven't listened to them yet, and I don't want to. Unfortunately, I'll be forced to listen.
I'm genuinely confused why a person working in the creative arts is so eager to turn his work over to a machine. I could probably make a quick buck by "writing" an AI novel, but I would hate myself, even though that would be a buck more than what I'm earning now. Writing as a human involves a lot of hard work, which is exactly why it's satisfying. Have we now exchanged pride for expediency?
A not-so-secret admission: a lot of our band's songs were not perfectly recorded. We work with the equipment we have, which is not exactly state of the art. And we work with the singer we have: me. I'm barely passable as a singer. I don't have much of a vocal range and I have a tendency to slide off-key, which requires multiple takes and a lot of splicing. My spouse's voice is better, but we're still limited to our recording setup. What we do possess is heart. Machines don't have a heart. They don't even know what heart is, except in the dictionary definition of it.
I could pay Suno to have a female machine sing my songs, and she wouldn't make any mistakes, but would I be eager to show them off to people? For what purpose?
"Here's a machine singing."
"Well, 'she' sounds great."
"What about the song?"
"Uh, yea, that, too. Did AI write it? Great job!"
I've now been completely eliminated from the process.
At least if I sing it, I'll get whatever credit is due.
Now my spouse wants to give Suno a try. He wants to bring some of his older songs to life. Maybe it's a male thing. Or rather, a male ego thing. He's not proud of the way they were recorded and he wants a chance to admire his work. I try to relate to that, but I can't. If Suno does one of my songs, it's not my song anymore.
That's my feeling about AI-written fiction. No, none of my books are perfect. A few are far from perfect. But they have heart and they sprung from my imagination. I won't be re-reading them, just like I'll never listen to some of my songs again.
But I still don't regret the work and creativity I poured into them.
That's worth far more than a buck or two.

Comments
Post a Comment
Your comments are welcome! Feel free to help your fellow writers or comment on anything you please. (Spam will be deleted.)